My 8th graders were NOT getting inferences.
I had been working with Module 1 for the past few weeks, where they were supposed to learn how to infer what type of person Ha is.
Well,
One student, 3 weeks in, does not yet know Ha is a girl. He wrote for his test answer, "Ha is a cool guy...he is cool because the text says..."
Ha is a girl.
So they're not getting it. Following the modules blindly will never do it for them. So like any good teacher would, I knew I had to teach them another way.
First, I passed out a list of character traits. I explained that when they get a question like, "what can you infer about the type of person Ha is?", it's asking for a character trait about her.
One of my students offered, "oh so a character trait is like a personality trait?" Bingo.
Wanting them to practice inferring with something they actually GET and are interested in, I decided to practice it with music.
On Youtube, we looked up the song "Rude" by Magic! The singer is very persistent about marrying a girl he loves. He asks the father for permission to marry her, to be respectful, and go figure...the father says no. So we get to the chorus where he goes, "why you gotta be so rude? Don't you know I'm human too? Why you gotta be so rude? I'm gonna marry her anyway."
He then proceeds to say that love him or hate him, tough dad cause they're getting married. And they "will run away, to another galaxy."
So I asked the students...what character traits can we infer?
It was beautiful.
I got:
-determined
-brave
-respectful
-and yet....one could also argue, disrespectful
-annoying
-persistent
And then I asked, what lyrics tell you this?
The students loved paraphrasing me the answers (which is GREAT...for our next skill we will need later...) so I was very pushy in saying, give me the actual, exact text that tells you this. And then I pushed them even further to explain it to me...how does this say he is being brave?
Moral of the story...I know we are under pressure from our schools to do things like "follow the modules", "follow this curriculum", "follow this script"...but you know what? Robots and computers can't be teachers, because when your kids aren't getting it, only a teacher can recognize this and try a different way.
No comments:
Post a Comment